Decoding AI Adoption: 6 Key Rules to Separate Authentic Innovation from the Hype

AI has become the hottest buzzword of the decade, with chatGPT—last year alone growing to 100,000,000 users within three months—the fastest growth in a new product ever. Since then, everyone, from startups to old-line businesses, has rushed to claim they are doing it.

It’s no wonder, as McKinsey’s report, “Mind the Gap: AI Leaders Pulling Ahead” has shown that companies adopting AI are growing faster than their competitors. For investors and finance, understanding whether a company uses AI properly now translates into wasting money or reaping rewards. So how can you tell whether a company is a poser or the real deal?

All AI projects start with people. 

AI is complex to implement well, requiring companies to select a robust use case and carefully consider the consequences for a successful implementation. Let’s start by looking at some clear pretenders.

Rule 1: Avoid Overreliance on Vendor APIs

If a startup relies on OpenAI or Anthropic to power its backend, it may not have a genuine grasp of its technological direction. Entrusting their core operations to external platforms leaves them vulnerable, lacking control over their future trajectory. Moreover, while prominent vendors may offer seemingly attractive pricing, the startup risks becoming entangled in a dependency loop with little autonomy over its technological infrastructure. Given the fluid nature of AI development, relying on these platforms poses the additional challenge of uncertain long-term access. Hence, startups should exercise caution when seeking financing for or implementing services from such providers.

Rule 2: Ensure Proper Board Oversight

When evaluating a mainline company’s claim of adopting AI, scrutiny of its board of directors becomes paramount. Who on the board has the experience and knowledge about AI to ask the right questions? How is the risk being managed? Who is responsible for governance and compliance? Suppose all the board members have technology knowledge ten years out of date, or worse yet, little to no relevant technological understanding of AI. How do you know if a joint venture will enhance shareholder value? How do you know this company is properly controlling the risks and potential of AI?

Rule 3: The CEO Needs to Assemble a Cross-Functional AI Team

What is the CEO’s role in AI integration? Enabling AI enterprise-wide requires CEO leadership, not limited to one department. A well-coordinated effort across Finance, HR, Legal, Data Analytics and IT is essential. If IT adopts tools like Copilot from Microsoft as they are already using other Microsoft packages, considerations include user adoption, risks, data security, and alignment with business objectives. Is the AI strategy well-conceived to leverage its full potential?

Rule 4: The CEO Needs to Champion Targeted Use Cases

Identify CEOs who actively champion specific AI use cases within their organizations. Concrete examples of use cases not only drive efficiency and service improvement but also enable the development of new capabilities. A competent CEO should possess a thorough understanding of these use cases, beyond mere acknowledgment of generic AI adoption. While most companies stand to benefit from AI, the key lies in strategic applications. Finance teams should rigorously assess the financial viability of AI initiatives to ensure a favorable return on investment (ROI). Prioritize projects with well-defined goals that closely align with the organization’s overarching business objectives.

Rule 5: Start Focused vs Diffuse AI Adoption

Exercise caution when encountering companies attempting to integrate AI into every aspect of their operations without adequate experience. While technology-focused giants like Microsoft, Google, Amazon, and Meta can swiftly adopt AI due to their expertise, smaller companies like Acme Bolts should proceed with more discernment. While embracing AI is crucial for staying competitive to keep up or leapfrog its competitors, overzealous adoption without proper experience can lead to detrimental outcomes. These companies must prioritize gaining experience and proficiency in implementing and managing AI solutions effectively before attempting widespread integration.

Rule 6: Carefully Select External Partners

Has the company assembled the right team for implementing AI solutions? Given the complexity of AI, most companies lack the requisite expertise to implement it independently. Is the company selecting the right partners for collaboration? A comprehensive strategy will include various stakeholders, including data providers, technology experts, and compliance managers, to ensure a holistic approach to AI integration.

AI implementation revolves around people. The success of large-scale projects like this hinges on securing buy-in from stakeholders at every level. It’s crucial to meticulously plan the business cases, develop appropriate strategies and policies for AI usage, and establish robust governance, auditing, and risk management frameworks. All these critical steps require human input and careful consideration. Ensuring alignment within the entire C-Suite on key aspects of the AI program is essential for its effective execution.

Over the next 20 years, AI will revolutionize business even more profoundly than the internet did. Companies that fail to adapt to this paradigm shift will get crushed, or at best, risk being left behind as AI becomes integral to the workplace. Recognizing that AI solutions are not one-size-fits-all, but rather customized to each company’s unique needs is paramount. Finance and banking sectors, in particular, need to be aware of the opportunities and risks presented by AI. They must cultivate the ability to assess proposed AI implementations critically and understand their impact on company valuations. With AI set to permeate every sector, it is imperative for the finance industry to embrace AI now to remain competitive in the future.

Written by: Dr Oliver King-Smith is CEO of smartR AI, a company which develops applications based on their SCOTi® AI and alertR frameworks.